|
Catherine Drinker
Bowen
Winner of the 1958
NONFICTION AWARD for
THE LION AND THE THRONE
Biographers, in the course of their business, experience
many hazards. There is the danger of ascribing to history
a soul, a conscious will to a nation. Individuals --
let alone nations-have not a steady will. Rather, they
proceed by plunges, one day loyal to their friends,
the next day treacherous even to themselves. The biographer
must not let herself be tempted into drawing a straight
line that leads to some neat historical or moralistic
pole.
There is the temptation to slip into antiquarianism,
a listing of genealogies, costumes, furnishments --
the sterile part of history. Twenty years ago, when
I was writing about Tchaikovsky, my Russian collaborator
used to tell me, "We must beware of the samovars and
the wolves." With Sir Edward Coke it was the fluted
ruffs, the silver armor, the Spanish galleons. Bad theater
can obscure the best of plots.
Dr. Johnson said that a historian will turn over an
entire library for the sake of one book. Here is a real
occupational hazard: the biographer may be crippled
by the fear that she is making the mere work of compilation.
To sit reading in a room surrounded by ten thousand
volumes, shelved and looking down, can make an author
truly queasy. "How," asks a seventeenth-century biographer,
"how shall I defend myself, that I thrust my labours
into the world? What warrant can I plead, that I build
a new Cottage upon the Waste?"
|