Susan Campbell
Bartoletti:
Good evening. I am speaking for the entire
panel of judges for the Young People's Literature
Award when I say that it has been an honor to
participate in this year's National Book Awards
judging process. I'd like to express our deep
gratitude to Neil Baldwin, and his hardworking
staff and to the National Book Foundation for
their service and dedication.
I'd also like to thank my fellow judges, Lulu
Delacré, Jean Craighead George, Barbara
Harrison and Margaret Tice. I could not have asked
for a better panel. Their keen insights and passion
brought clarity and positive energy to the discussion
of each book. If someone were to ask me what it's
like to judge the National Book Awards, I'd have
to say that it felt as though we were stealing
fire from the gods. It felt as though we were
fire bringers.
Tonight it's a pleasure to see so many fire bringers,
so many people who light the way for literacy
in one room. Fire bringing is an act of courage
because it's an act of truth, passion and hope.
One of the foremost fire bringers in the field
of literature for young people, Newbery Award
Winner, Katherine Patterson, once said that she
doesn't have two sets of truths, one for adults
and one for children. I'd like to add to that
by saying that the quality and diversity of this
year's entries revealed that writers of literature
for young people don't have two sets of truths,
nor do they have two sets of standards, one for
adults and one for children.
The excellence of this year's entries honors
this act of fire bringing. The books reveal that
there are few or no subject boundaries left between
books for young people and books for adults. The
authors are as diverse as their subject matter.
They are established writers and emerging writers.
They tell old stories in fresh ways; they tell
new stories in timeless ways. They tell stories
that are familiar and stories that break forms
and conventions.
During each conference call, our committee rejoiced
over each new story. We discussed and debated
and celebrated. We agonized and, yes, we mourned
as we winnowed our list. We talked about those
elements of craft and technique that make a story
distinct but as much as we could quantify certain
elements, there was always that inexplicable something
that made a story burn with truth, passion and
hope in our hearts. You see, it always comes back
to fire.
What does this say about the state of young people's
literature? It's about how much fire a writer
has the courage to steal from the gods and bring
to the story. It's about how much truth and how
much passion, for these are the elements that
light the way for hope.
The winner of the National Book Award for Young
People's Literature in 2003 is such a fire bringer.
The winner is The Canning Season by Polly
Horvath.